Contract question · Limitation of liability
Exclusion of consequential loss and loss of profit
Short answer
English courts have read "consequential loss" narrowly as loss within the second limb of Hadley v Baxendale (1854), so that a bare exclusion may leave direct loss of profit recoverable (British Sugar v NEI Power Projects [1997] EWCA Civ 2438).
German law has no statutory category of consequential loss; lost profit is part of recoverable damage (§ 252 BGB). An exclusion under either law should list the heads of loss it covers.
Range and benchmark
| Metric | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| English law reading | second limb of Hadley v Baxendale | British Sugar v NEI (1997) |
| German law | no category; lost profit recoverable | § 252 BGB |
| Drafting | list heads of loss: profit, production, use, financing, third-party contracts | contract practice |
| Carve-outs, German standard terms | intent, gross negligence, personal injury | § 309 No. 7 BGB |
Counter-proposal
Typical demand of the other side
The supplier is liable for all direct and indirect losses, including loss of production and loss of profit.
Counter-proposal, generic example (not taken from customer contracts)
Neither party shall be liable to the other for loss of profit, loss of production, loss of use, financing costs or claims of third parties under contracts of the other party, whether such loss is direct or indirect, except in case of wilful misconduct, gross negligence or death or personal injury.
Related questions
- Is "indirect loss" the same as "consequential loss"?
- In English case law the two are usually read together as second-limb loss; the safer drafting lists the heads of loss.
- Does the exclusion apply to both parties?
- Only if drafted as mutual. A one-sided exclusion leaves the other party exposed to the same heads of loss.
- Is an exclusion of lost profit valid in German standard terms?
- Between businesses it is generally valid for slight negligence, subject to the carve-outs of § 309 No. 7 BGB applied through § 307 BGB.
Sources
As of 17 November 2026. Statutory texts retrieved on 17 November 2026; case law with date and reference.
Further pages
Review of your own contract
CLEVER reviews your contract clause by clause against the supplier-side register and gives, for each finding, the location, the rating and a counter-proposal in the contract language.
Not legal advice. CLEVER produces draft wording for internal review; your own legal or contract team decides. No legal services within the meaning of the German Legal Services Act (RDG).