Industry · Energy
Contract risk in energy projects
Power plants, grid and substation assets, wind and solar parks are built under EPC, supply and installation contracts, run under operation and maintenance contracts and stand on land secured by land use agreements. CLEVER reviews these contracts against the seller register of 414 and the buyer register of 124 entries.
Performance guarantees of the plant, availability in operation, land rights and lenders’ step-in rights are entries of their own in the register. An amount in the contract’s currency only with a recorded contract value.
Problem · Benefit · Solution
Starting point and solution
Contract forms
Register topics
Number of entries per topic in the seller and buyer register.
Performance guarantees of the plant
Output and availability guarantee, net against gross output, heat rate and efficiency, test conditions, first-of-a-kind technology.
Seller register: 10 entriesOperation and maintenance
Scope of the O&M contract, availability targets, outages, spare parts and stock, reporting rights.
Seller register: 8 entriesLand for energy assets
Rent and commitment period, decommissioning and its security, easement and land register, grid connection and offtake as project conditions.
Seller register: 31 entries · Buyer register: 21 entriesLenders’ step-in rights
Triggers, scope of the direct agreement, cure rights, novation, lender consent.
Seller register: 5 entriesSubstance regimes
SF6 ban under the F-gas regulation, PCB, PFAS, RoHS, REACH candidate list, take-back at end of life.
Seller register: 9 entriesChange in law and permits
Costs from change in law, change of permit as change in law, timing risk and revocation of permits.
Seller register: 16 entries
Features
- Contract review and risk table SEEA finding per clause with a traffic light, a rating and rationale, checked against the reference register.
- Counter-proposal SEEAn insertable counter-proposal per finding, in the language of the contract.
- Materiality in contract currency SEEAmount per clause: minimum, likely, maximum. Only with a recorded contract value; without it a dash appears, not a zero.
- Multi-document and precedence TEAMUp to twenty documents per contract, such as main agreement and annexes, with precedence.
- Versions and second review TEAMSeveral versions and assessment runs of a contract, each dated.
- Risk reduction TEAMA proposed action per finding: what can be done to reduce the risk.
- Opposing view BUSINESSYour own contract, read against the other side’s register: 124 entries from the buyer’s side.
- Gap analysis BUSINESSSeller’s and buyer’s view of the same contract, the difference per clause.
- Delta analysis BUSINESSTwo versions of the same contract, compared clause by clause: what changed since the previous round.
Package from which the feature is included. Each tier includes the modules of the tier below. Prices
Use cases
EPC bid
Performance guarantees, liquidated damages and liability in the draft EPC contract before the bid is submitted, with a counter-proposal in the contract language.
Operation contract
Availability targets, outages and spare parts in the O&M contract, next to the EPC contract in one case.
Land rights
Land use agreement from the landowner’s or the user’s side, both views of the same contract per clause.
Coverage
Covered are the topics above. Step-in rights and the direct agreement are entries of their own, performance guarantees are entries of their own next to the general guarantees.
No entries of their own
- Power purchase agreements (PPA): no entries of their own.
- German agricultural lease law (sections 585 ff. BGB): no entries of its own; the land entries concern land made available for energy assets.
- Grid connection agreement with the system operator: no entries of its own.
Distinction
CLEVER assesses the contracts of an energy project clause by clause. Yield forecast, grid planning and the financial model stay in the project development tools; the legal review stays with the legal or contract team.
Effort and coverage
The calculator on the overview works with your own figures: contracts per year, contracts reviewed today, minutes per review and hourly rate. Alongside: experience values from comparable earlier projects.
To the calculator →Data security and responsibility
The six answers on training, providers, encryption, evidence, misreading and responsibility are on the overview.
To the overview →Next step
A demonstration on a sample contract from your function, with the contract types you handle most often.
Not legal advice. CLEVER produces draft wording for internal review; your own legal or contract team decides. No legal services within the meaning of the German Legal Services Act (RDG).