Industry · Mobility
Contract risk in mobility projects
Rail, road, airports and ports: infrastructure and rolling stock projects run under construction, supply and installation contracts, maintenance contracts with availability targets and the operators’ purchasing terms. Common feature: work on infrastructure in operation, a public or operator-related employer, maintenance over the service life.
CLEVER reviews these contracts against the general entries of the seller register for project contracts and against entries of their own on approval, safety case, train control, maintenance, concession and PPP projects from the contractor’s side and works during airport operation. 18 entries in the buyer register name as market standard the purchasing terms of a European rail transport and infrastructure group; in the seller register the same source appears once as a reference.
Problem · Benefit · Solution
Starting point and solution
Contract forms
Register topics
Number of entries per topic in the seller and buyer register.
Schedule, delay and liquidated damages
Extension of time, concurrent delay, milestone delay, delay damages rate and overall cap.
Seller register: 15 entriesWarranty and defects liability
Warranty period, latent defects, serial and batch defects, restart of the period after every repair, access costs of repair.
Seller register: 16 entriesLiability caps
Effective cap, exceptions, per-event against aggregate cap, time limit, flow-down to third parties.
Seller register: 13 entriesOperation and maintenance
Scope and exclusions, availability targets, outages, spare parts, handover at the end of the contract.
Seller register: 8 entriesSite and permits
Site access and rights of way, ground conditions, archaeological finds, allocation and revocation of permits.
Seller register: 16 entriesMarket standard rail
Entries with market standard or reference from the purchasing terms of a European rail transport and infrastructure group.
Seller register: 1 entry · Buyer register: 18 entriesForeign subsidies in procurement
Notification threshold of the Foreign Subsidies Regulation, ex officio review, contractual representations, thresholds in public procurement.
Seller register: 4 entriesVehicle authorisation and safety case
Authorisation for placing on the market, cut-off date for TSIs, new authorisation after an upgrade, safety case with independent assessment (CSM-RA, RAMS).
Seller register: 4 entries · Buyer register: 4 entriesTrain control and signalling
ETCS baseline and system version, compatibility checks between vehicle and trackside.
Seller register: 1 entry · Buyer register: 1 entryMaintenance and life cycle of rolling stock
Entity in charge of maintenance (ECM), life-cycle costs as a commitment.
Seller register: 2 entries · Buyer register: 2 entriesConcession and PPP projects
Flow-down of the project agreement to the contractor, pass-through of availability deductions to the maintenance contractor, modification during the term, maintenance contract beyond the end of the public service contract.
Seller register: 4 entries · Buyer register: 4 entriesWorks during airport operation
Work windows and closure times, change approval, background checks and airport identification cards.
Seller register: 1 entry · Buyer register: 1 entryWorks under rail traffic
Rail possessions and capacity restrictions, publication by the infrastructure manager, relocation and cancellation.
Seller register: 1 entry · Buyer register: 1 entryConstruction contract under German law and public works contracts
Security under section 650f BGB, employer’s security, material price adjustment clause, disruption and construction time, instructions under section 650b BGB, partial acceptance and condition survey, delay penalty in the employer’s terms, design contract, ground conditions in public works contracts.
Seller register: 8 entries · Buyer register: 9 entries
Features
- Contract review and risk table SEEA finding per clause with a traffic light, a rating and rationale, checked against the reference register.
- Counter-proposal SEEAn insertable counter-proposal per finding, in the language of the contract.
- Protection checklist SEEA rule check for missing must-have clauses, such as a liability cap or jurisdiction.
- Materiality in contract currency SEEAmount per clause: minimum, likely, maximum. Only with a recorded contract value; without it a dash appears, not a zero.
- Multi-document and precedence TEAMUp to twenty documents per contract, such as main agreement and annexes, with precedence.
- Risk reduction TEAMA proposed action per finding: what can be done to reduce the risk.
- Opposing view BUSINESSYour own contract, read against the other side’s register: 124 entries from the buyer’s side.
- Delta analysis BUSINESSTwo versions of the same contract, compared clause by clause: what changed since the previous round.
Package from which the feature is included. Each tier includes the modules of the tier below. Prices
Use cases
Operator tender
Draft contract and purchasing terms before the bid is submitted, read against the seller register and against the buyer-side register.
Vehicle and system supply
Warranty, spare parts availability and liability in the supply contract, with a counter-proposal in the contract language.
Maintenance
Availability targets and outages in the maintenance contract; new versions compared clause by clause with the previous round.
Coverage
Covered are the general entries for project contracts, operation and maintenance, warranty and liability, the rail market standard in the buyer register, and entries of their own on vehicle authorisation, safety case, train control, rolling stock maintenance, concession and PPP projects from the contractor’s side, works during airport and rail operation, and the construction contract under German law and public works contracts, each from the seller’s and the buyer’s side. The mobility entries of their own stay outside the scan catalogue until measured.
No entries of their own
- Toll systems and toll collection: no entries of their own.
Distinction
CLEVER assesses the supply, construction, maintenance and life-cycle contracts of a mobility project clause by clause. Not covered: operation of the infrastructure, demand and revenue risk of the operator or concessionaire, port services. Approval, safety cases and maintenance planning stay with the specialist departments; the legal review stays with the legal or contract team.
Effort and coverage
The calculator on the overview works with your own figures: contracts per year, contracts reviewed today, minutes per review and hourly rate. Alongside: experience values from comparable earlier projects.
To the calculator →Data security and responsibility
The six answers on training, providers, encryption, evidence, misreading and responsibility are on the overview.
To the overview →Next step
A demonstration on a sample contract from your function, with the contract types you handle most often.
Not legal advice. CLEVER produces draft wording for internal review; your own legal or contract team decides. No legal services within the meaning of the German Legal Services Act (RDG).