Menu
Sign in Demo

Contract question · Battle of the forms

Battle of the forms: English law, German law, CISG

Short answer

English law applies the "last shot" approach: the last set of terms sent before performance generally governs (Butler Machine Tool v Ex-Cell-O [1979] 1 WLR 401).

German courts apply the knock-out rule where both sides refer to their own terms and perform: conflicting terms drop out and statutory law applies (§ 306(2) BGB by analogy). The BGH applied the same approach under the CISG (BGH, 9 January 2002, VIII ZR 304/00).

Range and benchmark

MetricValueBasis
English lawlast shotButler Machine Tool v Ex-Cell-O (1979)
German lawknock-out; statutory law fills gaps§ 306(2) BGB; case law
CISGmaterial alteration is a counter-offer; knock-out in German case lawArt. 19 CISG; BGH VIII ZR 304/00
Simple retention of title, Germanyeffective despite defence clause§ 449 BGB; case law

Counter-proposal

Typical demand of the other side

Only the purchaser's terms apply; the supplier's terms are rejected even if the purchaser accepts delivery with knowledge of them.

Counter-proposal, generic example (not taken from customer contracts)

The parties agree the terms in Annex X as exhaustive. Neither the purchaser's purchase conditions nor the supplier's sales conditions form part of the contract.

Related questions

Does the order confirmation always win under English law?
Only if it is the last document before performance and the other side does not object; a signed framework agreement prevails.
What is a material alteration under the CISG?
Additional or different terms relating to price, payment, quality, quantity, place and time of delivery, liability or dispute settlement (Art. 19(3) CISG).
How can the conflict be avoided?
By a framework agreement or a signed contract stating which terms apply.

Sources

As of 17 November 2026. Statutory texts retrieved on 17 November 2026; case law with date and reference.

Further pages

Other languages: FrançaisEspañolPortuguêsالعربيةहिन्दी

Review of your own contract

CLEVER reviews your contract clause by clause against the supplier-side register and gives, for each finding, the location, the rating and a counter-proposal in the contract language.

Book a demoStart a trial3 contract reviews free, no credit card

Not legal advice. CLEVER produces draft wording for internal review; your own legal or contract team decides. No legal services within the meaning of the German Legal Services Act (RDG).