Contract question · Bonds and guarantees
On-demand guarantee under German law
Short answer
A clause in the employer's standard terms requiring a performance guarantee payable on first demand is invalid under German law (BGH, 18 April 2002, VII ZR 192/01; for public employers BGH, 25 March 2004, VII ZR 453/02).
VOB/B excludes guarantees on first demand as security (§ 17(4) VOB/B). In international projects under other laws, demand guarantees under URDG 758 are standard.
Range and benchmark
| Metric | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| German standard terms | on-demand performance guarantee invalid | BGH VII ZR 192/01 |
| VOB/B | on-demand guarantee cannot be required | § 17(4) VOB/B |
| Individually negotiated | permitted | § 305(1) BGB |
| International practice | URDG 758 demand guarantees | ICC |
Counter-proposal
Typical demand of the other side
Irrevocable guarantee on first demand, waiving all defences.
Counter-proposal, generic example (not taken from customer contracts)
Unlimited, directly enforceable (selbstschuldnerische) guarantee by an EU-licensed bank or credit insurer, waiving the defence of prior enforcement against the principal debtor.
Related questions
- What replaces an invalid clause?
- The court interprets the contract as requiring an unlimited, directly enforceable guarantee without the on-demand feature (BGH VII ZR 192/01).
- Does the rule apply to advance payment guarantees?
- An advance payment guarantee secures repayment of money already paid; courts treat it differently from performance security.
- Does it apply under English law?
- No. The German rule applies where German law governs the security agreement.
Sources
- Federal Court of Justice (BGH), judgment of 18.04.2002, VII ZR 192/01
- Federal Court of Justice (BGH), judgment of 25.03.2004, VII ZR 453/02
- ICC Uniform Rules for Demand Guarantees (URDG 758)
- German Civil Code (BGB), English translation
As of 17 November 2026. Statutory texts retrieved on 17 November 2026; case law with date and reference.
Further pages
Review of your own contract
CLEVER reviews your contract clause by clause against the supplier-side register and gives, for each finding, the location, the rating and a counter-proposal in the contract language.
Not legal advice. CLEVER produces draft wording for internal review; your own legal or contract team decides. No legal services within the meaning of the German Legal Services Act (RDG).