Contract question · Liquidated damages
Liquidated damages and penalty: English and German law
Short answer
Under English law a liquidated damages clause is unenforceable as a penalty if it imposes a detriment out of all proportion to a legitimate interest of the innocent party in performance (Cavendish v Makdessi [2015] UKSC 67).
German law distinguishes the contractual penalty (§§ 339 ff. BGB), which exerts pressure and fixes a minimum, from lump-sum damages, which in standard terms must allow proof of a lower loss (§ 309 No. 5 BGB).
Range and benchmark
| Metric | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| English law test | out of all proportion to a legitimate interest | Makdessi [2015] UKSC 67 |
| German contractual penalty | pressure and minimum damages | §§ 339, 340(2) BGB |
| German lump-sum damages in standard terms | proof of lower loss to be allowed | § 309 No. 5 BGB |
| Negotiated contracts, English law | strong presumption that parties judged the interest | Makdessi |
Counter-proposal
Typical demand of the other side
The supplier pays 1% of the contract value per week as liquidated damages; proof of a lower loss is excluded.
Counter-proposal, generic example (not taken from customer contracts)
The supplier pays liquidated damages of 0.5% of the price of the delayed part per completed week, up to 5% of that price. The supplier may prove that no loss or a lower loss has occurred.
Related questions
- Is "liquidated damages" in a German-law contract a penalty?
- German courts classify the clause by purpose and wording, not by its label. A clause meant to exert pressure regardless of loss is a contractual penalty.
- Does a genuine pre-estimate of loss still matter in English law?
- After Makdessi the question is the legitimate interest, not only a pre-estimate of loss; a pre-estimate remains a strong indication that the clause is not penal.
- Is VAT charged on liquidated damages in Germany?
- A contractual penalty is compensation, not consideration for a supply; German administrative practice treats it as outside the scope of VAT (section 1.3(3) of the VAT Application Decree).
Sources
As of 17 November 2026. Statutory texts retrieved on 17 November 2026; case law with date and reference.
Further pages
Review of your own contract
CLEVER reviews your contract clause by clause against the supplier-side register and gives, for each finding, the location, the rating and a counter-proposal in the contract language.
Not legal advice. CLEVER produces draft wording for internal review; your own legal or contract team decides. No legal services within the meaning of the German Legal Services Act (RDG).