Menu
Sign in Demo

Insights · 24 September 2026

LD at 10 %, 30 % chance: what decides if that is acceptable?

Reasoning per clause, hierarchy of reference values, opportunities beside risks, contracts without a contract value, legal systems and data handling.

Liquidated damages at 10 % of the contract value. 30 % chance of being triggered. What decides whether that is acceptable? Market practice? FIDIC? Or your own last five projects?

My recent posts on CLEVER brought a lot of questions from risk and commercial people. The answers are now in the product.

The reasoning comes before the number. Where does the probability come from? From a reasoning per clause: what can happen, what it would cost, how likely that is in this type of deal. It is what you should challenge.

The benchmark hierarchy. Which reference value is a clause measured against? The closest one available:

1 · the project requirement
2 · your company's own standard
3 · codes and standards (FIDIC, Orgalim, statute)
4 · CLEVER's experience base
5 · market practice

Where a source exists, it is shown with its type of evidence. Where it is missing, that is shown too.

Opportunities do not erase risks. Bonuses and incentives written into the contract are proposed as opportunities and confirmed by the person accountable for the deal (we call this role Deal Manager). CLEVER shows risks, opportunities and the balance — but the portfolio keeps counting the risks.

No contract value? Then CLEVER shows only amounts the contract itself states. A figure without a reference looks like a measurement and is not one.

Legal systems. 139 country statements now carry a statutory source with the date it was retrieved — Germany, England, the US, Singapore, Australia, France, Spain, Brazil, the UAE. What is not yet evidenced is marked "under review" rather than asserted. More countries and updates follow week by week.

Your data. Stored in Frankfurt. Each customer sees only their own rows — a rule inside the database that applies before any role check, not in the interface; a dedicated database is available as an option. For the analysis the text goes to the model provider, is deleted there within 30 days and is never used for training. Processing exclusively inside the EU can be booked as a commitment […].

From now on I will post here every week — what is new, or what deserves a closer look.

A question to everyone in bid and commercial risk management: how do you capture lessons from closed projects so the next bid actually uses them? If you want to test this on a real contract: message me.

Happy Selling! 🙂
Juergen

clever-ai.org

LD at 10 %, 30 % chance: what decides if that is acceptable?
Screenshot from CLEVER with invented or public data.

Published on LinkedIn on 24 September 2026. Figures and feature statements apply on that day. View the post on LinkedIn →

Next step

A demonstration on a sample contract from your function, with the contract types you handle most often.

Book a demoStart a trial3 contract reviews free, no payment details